Home | Contact     
      Home
      Editorial board
      Database listing
      Submission
      Review
      Archives
      Contact
Faculty of Economics and Business Administration

Str. Teodor Mihali, Nr. 58-60 400591, Cluj Napoca, Romania
Tel: +40.264 41 86 52/3/4/5
Fax: +40.264 41 25 70


Reviewing Process

According to the decision of the editorial board, aiming to improve the quality standards, the process of reviewing the articles submitted consists of the following steps:
- articles are sent to the editors to the e-mail mccs@econ.ubbcluj.ro The fulfilment of all requirements is verified according to the author guidelines;
- the editors distribute the manuscripts to specialized national and international reviewers, after having ensured the anonymity of the authors;
- the manuscript is accompanied by the review evaluation form;
- reviewers are required to make the observations and comments in writing on 1-3 pages, which are sent to the editors and submitted back to the authors, to revise the manuscript;
- recommendations aims at one of the four situations: article accepted, accepted with minor changes, accepted with major improvements, and article rejected;
- along with the open feedback on 1-3 pages, reviewers must grade the manuscript according to the criteria set out in the appropriate form.

New Page 2

 

 

Score

1

Structure of the paper

 

2

Quality of the analysis/methodology

 

3

English quality

 

4

Personal contributions to knowledge

 

5

Likelihood to stimulate future research

 

6

Respects the template

 

7

Relevance to MCCS aims

 

8

Overall, the quality of the paper is

 

- the review form is transmitted to authors, ensuring the anonymity of the reviewers;
- according to the recommendations received the authors modify the manuscript and submit to the editors.

Home | Contact

Copyright © July, 2018 Econ.UBBCluj.ro. All rights reserved. Copyright Notice.
Webmaster Mican Daniel